Print this page

Q2: Development of tiered testing strategies: evaluation of (Q)SAR prediction models based on in vitro and in vivo metabolism – Deadline: August 31, 2008


Knowledge of the metabolism of chemicals is an important requirement to comply with REACH. This includes both qualitative and quantitative information, i.e., structures of metabolites and rates of concurrent pathways, with a particular focus on the situation in humans. The evaluation of these properties should follow a tiered approach starting with a review of existing literature and data, including data for related chemicals. The next tiers would include a (Q)SAR prediction and simple in vitro screening assays, followed by the use of more complex in vitro three-dimensional models. The highest tiers are testing in lower species and finally the traditional animal tests.

For REACH extensive data on the toxicological properties of chemicals and their potential metabolites will have to be acquired. In this context alternative test methods in line with the 3R principles (refinement, reduction, replacement) become increasingly more important to improve animal welfare. Besides in vitro test methods, in silico methods such as QSARs create further prospects for reducing animal testing.

A number of models and programmes have been developed to predict metabolic pathways on the basis of structural components, some of which are commercially available. The current limitation of (Q)SAR models resides in that they are biased to consider a far greater number of metabolites than actually observed. Prioritization based on these data risk to end in erroneous forecasts or may put too much emphasis on one of the two phases in metabolism (e.g. conjugation reactions, detoxification). However, validation is limited to in vitro data, and results of comparison between models regarding predictive value are not available in a comprehensive manner. This gap of knowledge should be filled.


This proposal is intended to enhance the predictive power of simulated in vitro metabolism by using metabolically active in vitro systems as well as published and proprietary in vivo metabolism data to clarify the accuracy of prediction of available tissue specific (Q)SAR metabolite prediction models. One potential outcome is the definition of a set of principles as guideline how to conduct and/or to constrain the (Q)SAR prediction. Where metabolite prediction results in erroneous prediction, a correction of the algorithms and improvement of the model could be sought in cooperation with the modeller (e.g. TIMES / LMC).


This RfP is addressed to laboratories that are familiar with (Q)SAR and/or metabolite profiling. The strategy is to connect in vitro, in vivo and in silico alternative methods to develop an intelligent testing strategy to identify chemicals with the potential to cause toxic effects. Collaborative work might be needed and respective projects are welcome. The aim is a comparison of various models for their predictive value for in vivo metabolism. The analysis should be based on a selection of chemicals of different structural classes. The benchmark should ideally be the metabolism in humans, but data available from rats could constitute a first step.

The Proposal should state

  • The models to be used
  • The chemicals to be investigated
  • The data on metabolism to which the prediction is confronted
  • The gaps of knowledge and the approach to fill them
  • The quantitative and statistical criteria to analyze the fits
  • The new physicochemical descriptors used for modelling metabolism data
  • The data mining methods being used

Short interim reports on progress are required at 6-monthly intervals. It is expected that the findings will developed into a peer reviewed publication, following presentation at a suitable scientific conference.

Related links

Q2 QSAR Metabolism

Timing: Project start in 2008, project duration up to 2 years

LRI funding: Budget in the order of 150,000 Euro


© Copyright 2014 Cefic | European Chemical Industry Council. All rights reserved | Terms and Conditions of Use